Guaranteed Win Night for the Rangers

Written by Dan David

The Hockey Draft Central site is growing slowly but surely. The most recent addition is the complete 1999 QMJHL Midget Draft that featured No. 1 pick Chris Montgomery.

The fact that the Q’s top pick in 1999 never made it as a pro demonstrates how hard it is to spot NHL talent. It was also hard for NHL scouts that year, as the No. 1 pick was Patrik Stefan. The scouts who got it right at No. 1 in 1999 were working in the OHL. Their pick was a guy named Jason Spezza.

Speaking of being No. 1, let me digress into something about these Stanley Cup playoffs …

When I worked at Madison Square Garden, I used to predict what I called “Guaranteed Win Nights” for the New York Rangers. I would allow myself to declare only three Guaranteed Win Nights per season, and they had to be declared on the day of the game.

I don’t remember the Rangers ever losing on Guaranteed Win Night, but if they did, it only happened once or twice.

This year’s Rangers team is far better than any team they had when I worked there. I would argue it’s the best Rangers team in history, and it was primarily built through the draft, trades for other teams’ prospects, and remarkable scouting of undrafted free agents.

Eventually, I plan to write about why and how this team was so brilliantly constructed. I’ll explain why I’m convinced this team will win the Stanley Cup this year and is on the verge of a mini-dynasty. I will wait at least until the start of the next playoff round to write that.

For now, let me just say this — a little more than five hours before they drop the puck for Game 4 in Washington:

It’s Guaranteed Win Night for the New York Rangers.

I’m feeling it.

Sorry, Capitals fans.

Without Wuest, Game Can Never Be the Same

Written by Dan David

For the past few days, I was planning to write about why I believe the New York Rangers are an absolute lock to win this year’s Stanley Cup. I was going to explain how this year’s team was brilliantly built through the draft, free agency, and trades and how happy I will be for so many former MSG and Rangers co-workers when the Cup is presented to Ryan McDonagh in June.

I was going to write about how I felt fortunate to have been working for the team when almost all of the current homegrown players were drafted and how emotional it will be to see McDonagh pass the Cup to Henrik Lundqvist, who is truly one of the best people in the game and could not be more deserving of such an honor.

Matthew Wuest

Matthew Wuest

Of course, I still look forward to that Cup-lifting moment — and it will happen, believe me. However, that is all I can say about these Rangers just 48 hours from the start of the playoffs, because my thoughts today have been focused on the memory of someone who passed away nearly four weeks ago.

I wasn’t paying any attention to hockey headlines when Matthew Wuest lost his battle with cancer last month. Focused solely on hockey’s past, researching the history of major-junior drafts, I had little time for the present. And so, regrettably, I missed the news that Matt, best known as the creator of, had passed away.

In some ways, I am thankful I did not learn of Matt’s death at the time. I knew for months that Matt had a terminal illness, but his loss is a devastating thing for me to digest and learning of it when he has already been laid to rest makes it somehow easier to absorb.

Flipping through The Hockey News pages today, I saw that Matt was gone. It was a surreal moment. I knew Matt when he dreamed of getting a by-line in The Hockey News, and here I was looking at a full-page obituary.

I spent the next two hours reviewing all the online coverage of his death, including the Halifax newspaper obituary, tributes from fellow hockey journalists and fans, and the numerous Twitter mentions of him in the days around this incredibly saddening news. I will continue to read anything and everything I can about Matt, but I have to write, too. Years from now, if someone searches Matt’s name online, I hope they will find this story in the mix.

Like so many others who have saluted Matt’s life, I never met him in person, but for almost 15 years he was a loyal friend. From the start, I was awed by his passion. As he made a name for himself in hockey, I was awed by his humility. And when I learned that he was so very ill, I was awed by his courage.

Life is random, and it is not fair. Period. There is no other rational way to explain how a person this selfless could be taken from all of us at such a young age.

I came to this very conclusion 21 years ago when my cousin, one of the kindest people I have ever known, passed away due to cancer at age 43. Matt was even younger — only 35 when he died last month — yet he had come a long, long way from when we first crossed paths.

It was the summer of 2000, and I was working at an ill-fated dot-com called Rival Networks. The company’s flagship website,, was ahead of its time in recognizing the demand for fan-generated sports content, but had no real way to monetize it. This was still a pre-broadband world and a time when people were leery of shopping online. Like so many other dot-coms in 2000, Rivals Networks was hoping for an IPO which would make its founders rich. Due to mismanagement and the dot-com collapse, the company never got to that point. (Side Note: The brand was later revived as a college football recruiting site by a small group of former employees and sold to Yahoo! for big money, but that’s another story.)

Armed with tens of millions of dollars in dot-com venture-capital funding, Rival Networks had managed to aggregate hundreds of the best unofficial sports team sites under one umbrella. At the time, it seemed ridiculous for amateurs to be writing about teams that wouldn’t even consider giving them press credentials, and it seemed even sillier to have ridiculously biased hockey fans trying to “report” on their favorite teams. My friends in mainstream journalism mocked me for joining such a company, and they were right in the sense that I would be out of work in only 11 months.

That 11-month ride that still seems like a dream. During those 11 months, I oversaw the company’s network of hockey sites, which drew most of their traffic from popular message boards. The words “blog” and “social media” probably didn’t exist at the time, Mark Zuckerberg was still in high school, and Twitter was five or six years away from existing, so those message boards were the cutting edge of interactivity.

Our Detroit Red Wings site was run by a fighter pilot named Barry. It didn’t have much traffic, because Barry was often busy flying jets and couldn’t put much time into working on it. As a result, Barry had to find an assistant to help him run the site.

That assistant ended up being a 19-year-old Canadian student named Matthew Wuest.

Although he had grown up in Maritime Canada, Matt was a die-hard Red Wings fan. He had discovered Barry’s site shortly after it launched in 1999 and really liked the Rival Networks concept. However, like most of the other people in our network, he had absolutely no experience as a journalist.

Matt was primarily interested in Red Wings draft picks and prospects, so he started out by helping Barry in that area. His early articles did not feel particularly professional, but they were always thorough, accurate, and highly informative. It was obvious that this kid from New Brunswick really, really cared about the Red Wings’ future.

He was particularly focused on a couple of European prospects named Henrik Zetterberg and Pavel Datsyuk, and he was tracking their progress on a daily basis. Both players were late-round picks, and very little was known about them in North America. Matt, however, was a true believer and did everything he could to alert Red Wings fans to their potential greatness. Matt, being Matt, was way ahead of his time.

As the months passed, Matt took more control of the Rivals Red Wings site. While Barry had been my initial phone contact, more of the conversations were now with Matt. These long-distance calls from Seattle to New Brunswick were probably costing our company a fortune. Matt was determined to learn everything he could about journalism, and it was refreshing to speak with a young person who shared my passion for hockey in general and the draft in particular.

At the time, Matt was studying computer science. Because of his computer skills, he was able to do some cool things on the Red Wings site, and he had an unbelievable work-ethic. In fact, I have yet to see another 20-year-old with that kind of dedication and I’m sure I never will.

Shortly before Rivals collapsed in April 2001, Matt told me he had decided that writing about hockey was his true calling and he would shift from computer science to journalism. I remember thinking it was crazy to give up computer science for what would be a far less lucrative career covering sports, but this kid was determined and he certainly wasn’t risk-averse.

When the run ended, Matt took all of his passion to his own site, He built that site into everything a fan of Red Wings prospects could have dreamed of and began to establish connections in the scouting world. He would continue to publish that site for its loyal audience until just last year, when his declining health forced him to limit himself to CapGeek.

As he pursued his journalism degree, Matt began free-lancing for The Hockey News, and eventually became a sports reporter in Halifax, Nova Scotia, where he covered the local QMJHL team. Knowing Matt’s background, I always got a big kick out of reading his Hockey News pieces and seeing his QMJHL reporting online.

CapGeek was a spin-off of RedWingsCentral, which had ushered in the salary-cap era by providing contract and cap-hit information about the Red Wings alone. Given his natural coding ability, Matt was able to build something unique, and he had the foresight to realize he could expand his salary and contract database to cover the entire NHL — thereby filling a need that the league refused to address.

He did just that, and he revolutionized the world of hockey in the process. Everyone in the business used CapGeek for salary-related information. I remember seeing Cam Hope, then the assistant general manager of the Rangers, going through the CapGeek site one day and telling him I knew the guy who created it. Cam, who had helped put together all of the Rangers players’ actual contracts, said CapGeek was roughly 95 percent accurate in the case of the Rangers, and he marveled at how Matt Wuest was getting his information from player agents and other sources.

In 2011, I remember the excitement I felt when Matt was ranked No. 98 on The Hockey News‘ annual list of the 100 most powerful people in hockey. The kid from the phone calls had made it to the game’s stratosphere. It hardly surprised me. From those first conversations I had with him in 2000, I sensed that this person was destined to forever impact the game he loved. If it ever becomes possible for the Hockey Hall of Fame to honor online achievements in the way it honors writers and broadcasters, I would hope the award could be named for Matt.

The most impressive thing — and the thing I will always remember about Matt — was his remarkable humility and respect for the game. In a world of obnoxious bloggers and shameless self-promoters, Matt was never interested in the spotlight, and he was not about big money. There are dot-com dreamers out there who would give anything for what Matt had, but he cared about a bigger picture and was constantly sharing his love for hockey. He responded to every question that came his way and took every fan’s online request seriously, never forgetting that he was once one of them.

He also never forgot people he met along the way. When I started a twitter account for HockeyDraftCentral, Matt was the second person to follow me, even though I had not had e-mail contact with him in a couple of years. Last summer, I e-mailed him to ask if there was some way I could help him build out historical information on CapGeek, and I was genuinely excited about the prospect of working with him again after all these years.

Matt didn’t respond to that e-mail for several weeks, which wasn’t like him at all. But I had no idea he was nearly two years into a battle for his life. Then, in August, he e-mailed me to let me know that he couldn’t take me up on my offer because of his illness, which was not public information at the time.

I was stunned and saddened to learn he was sick, but I somehow thought that he was going to beat cancer. I had seen this young man go from obscurity in a New Brunswick computer-science program to the THN top 100. I had to believe that no matter how sick he was, he would find a way to survive.

I had one more e-mail exchange with Matt last November. He was going in for another round of treatment and seemed hopeful. He mentioned that he and Ottawa Senators GM Bryan Murray were fighting the exact same thing despite the big gap in their ages. It suddenly struck me that I had once met Bryan Murray in person but had never actually been in the same room as Matt.

So I knew he was sick, but subconsciously, I was avoiding the reality that his time was so limited. I hadn’t checked CapGeek since he shut it down in January, so I didn’t realize his health had declined so rapidly from November. I suppose that’s something I was afraid to know.

And now he is gone, and hockey will never be the same for his loss. He was remembered in most tribute pieces as an online pioneer, a person of great humility, a friend to all hockey fans and an inspiration to hockey writers. He was indeed all of those things, but none of those journalists had known Matt before he had joined their ranks. Few may have understood just how far he had come.

I will forever remember Matt as the young man on the phone going on to reach heights that might have seemed unimaginable. I was 34 when I had my first conversation with Matt. He was 35 when he died. In those intervening 15 years, he touched the lives of millions of hockey fans who spent countless hours interacting with both him and his work.

I have been looking forward to this year’s Stanley Cup playoffs for a long time, and I fully expect to feel a lot of happiness for a lot of Rangers people in June. But if any other team proves me wrong and takes the Cup instead of this great Rangers team, I want it to be the Detroit Red Wings. And no matter what happens during these playoffs, I will be thinking a lot about Matthew Wuest and how grateful I am to have known one of 21st century hockey’s most important and ground-breaking people.

A 1974 Typo Changed WHA Draft History

Written by Dan David

Forty years ago at the 1974 NHL Amateur Draft, Buffalo general manager Punch Imlach made¬† the Sabres the first and only NHL team to draft a player who didn’t exist.

Many hockey fans, particularly those in Buffalo, know the story of Taro Tsujimoto. The made-up Japanese phenom was an inside joke between Imlach and the Sabres PR director, Paul Wieland. During the endless conference call to draft amateurs, Wieland and Imlach decided to have some fun by selecting Tsujimoto in the 11th round.

Nobody had heard of Tsujimoto, but Imlach insisted he was a real player from Japan’s Tokyo Katanas, and the league diligently added his name to its draft list. Months would pass before Wieland and Imlach exposed the the joke to hockey insiders. Tsujimoto’s name appeared in draft lists on league and team publications for years.

The NHL had conducted its infamously tedious 1974 draft via conference call because it was trying to prevent the rival World Hockey Association from learning names of selected players before NHL teams had a chance to contact them. The WHA had made a similar pre-emptive strike months earlier, when it held two draft rounds in a a much shorter secret conference call.

The NHL’s 1974 conference call lasted several days — ending before the WHA’s non-secretive draft on May 31, 1974. The NHL list, including Tsujmoto’s name, was not released to the media until after the WHA picks were announced.

Nobody at the WHA knew about Tsujimoto at the time of that league’s own draft. But, as if not to be outdone by the NHL, the WHA also went for years listing a person who didn’t exist in its 1974 draft records.

Actually, it’s complicated, because the drafted player did exist, and if you live in Grand Rapids, Minn., you probably know him well.

His name is John Rothstein, a former Grand Rapids High School star who is now the school’s head coach. Rothstein was a legendary Minnesota high school hockey player, who led his team to a state championship as a senior in 1975 and then went on to an impressive college career at Minnesota-Duluth.¬† While he was in college, the Chicago Black Hawks made Rothstein the 115th pick in the 1976 NHL Amateur Draft.

In 1974, however, Rothstein was a junior at Grand Rapids and not well known outside of Minnesota high school hockey circles. At that time, the WHA’s Minnesota Fighting Saints were hoping to attract fans by drafting local high school kids, and because the league allowed them to choose players as young as 17, the Fighting Saints had an advantage over the NHL’s North Stars.

The Fighting Saints used their final pick in the draft, No. 204 overall, to select Rothstein. He joined fellow Minnesota high school stars Chick Yackel, Reed Larson, and Tony Dorn Jr., on the Minnesota list for 1974. Due to their age, none of these players were eligible for the NHL draft until 1976, and only Larson would end up being selected.

Unfortunately, someone who didn’t know Minnesota high schools that well was aked to record Rothstein’s name in the official WHA draft list distributed to the media. That same someone didn’t verify the name he was typing — or at least made a typo when recording it.

And that’s how the WHA inadvertenlty created a mythical player named John Rolstein.

The name John Rolstein was announced by the WHA as Minnesota’s final pick. The error found its way into the WHA draft list that appeared in the Sporting News’ 1974-75 Pro and Amateur Hockey Guide. The rest is history.

WHA historian Scott Surgent, author of the “Complete Historical and Statistical Reference to the World Hockey Association”, listed Rolstein in his outstanding book, which was first published during the Internet’s infancy in 1995. Today, if you type “John Rolstein” and “hockey” into Google, you get multiple results within various 1974 WHA draft lists. Rolstein’s name appears on popular reference sites such as,,, and

In other words, 40 years later, John Rolstein is still out there, chilling with Taro Tsujimoto in a world where people who don’t exist can forever insist they were once among the world’s very best amateur hockey players.